This breakup, however, seems to be more final, as Pauly D has since deleted all evidence of his time with Aubrey from Instagram, usually a telling move.
But the couple’s breakup does come as a surprise to fans.
We were having a difficult time with all of that, and we’ve figured out how to be the strongest team that we can be.
We both wanted to be together, and we weren’t willing to not let that happen.
Shortly after the couple’s first breakup, Aubrey told E!
Online, “It’s very difficult to build a relationship as a celebrity couple and have the personal life and the public come together as one.
Though they broke up for a short time back in May, they've since rekindled their romance.
"Relationships are tough as it is, but being in a celebrity relationship, it's even harder," the former "Jersey Shore" star tells toofab's Brian Particelli of their split. " To prove how devoted he is about his main girl, he even introduced her to his mother and daughter Amabella, who he shares with a VIP hostess with whom he had a one-night stand.
Also check out the video below to see what O'Day told us about her beau ...
and have been dating for six months — have moved right past calling each other "boyfriend" and "girlfriend" and straight to more serious terminology.
In fact, in the first episode, O'Day actually says there's "no substance" to him.
"It's funny because right off the bat, I didn't think that I was going to connect with her either because I really wasn't going there to connect with people inside the house," he explains now.
"Pauly's the complete opposite of anyone I've ever dated," O'Day said in a clip from the show, via E! "There isn't a lot of substance there and, honestly, I'm not interested." In fact, O'Day wasn't interested in anyone at first, and doubted that she would make a love connection on the show.